Arguments Against Marijuana Legalization

1394 Words3 Pages

The issue of marijuana, a center for debate in recent politics, is not necessarily a new one. Dangers, crime rates, medical uses and statistics are at the forefront of discussion for marijuana. However, the issue is actually the continued debate of states’ right versus federal rights. The division of rights between the states and the federal government have been argued since before our founding fathers wrote the Constitution. The question if federal laws should be enforced where marijuana is legal is the same argument as slavery during the Civil War era. Southern states wanted to have slavery while the federal government was trying to ban it. Now, states believe they have their right to produce and sell marijuana, while the federal government …show more content…

Opposers of the compact theory and antidrug activists both believe these federal laws should be enforced in the states that have legalized marijuana. Opposers who denounce the Compact theory do not honor the states in this system of government. Daniel Webster, a massachusetts state senator in 1830 who opposed of the compact theory, when discussing the federal government, argues that “the people brought it into existence, established it, and have hitherto supported it, for the very purpose, amongst others, of imposing certain salutary restraints on State sovereignties” (Webster). Therefore, the constitution is not a compact of states, it is a contract of American citizens. Webster opinions form the basis argument against the compact theory. Another argument as to why federal law must be enforced where marijuana is legal is because there are aspects of society that the states cannot control. Webster describes these aspects by saying “If this Constitution, Sir, be the creature of State legislatures, it must be admitted that it has obtained a strange control over the volitions of its creators. Some of these powers include declaring war and coining money, but when it comes to marijuana, interstate commerce, is one of those federal powers that keep marijuana illegal. According to David Evans, a special advisor for the Drug Free America Foundation, marijuana crosses state lines which is something individual states cannot control, therefore, federal laws must be enforced. (Evans). The other aspect in favor of allowing federal laws, is that marijuana is a dangerous drug with dangerous effects. The common effects of marijuana usage include “difficulty with thinking, problem solving, memory recall and learning, and distorted perception and impaired coordination” (Walsh). These few common symptoms scare people. People are scared to have people

Open Document