A Nice Manager

817 Words2 Pages

Chisum Industries likes to see their best managers progress in their careers. With locations across Texas, the opportunities to advance were plentiful. The promotion process allowed for the manager to make self-assessments about their “goals, strengths, and weakness” and to use their experiences to make their case for advancement (Daft, 2014, p.487). In addition, the candidates were observed in their work environment by a promotion committee consisting of the company's top management (Daft, 2014, p.487). This committee would observe the manager and the interactions they had with their employees. The last step would involve interviews at the home office.
Harry Creighton was a finalist for the top position at the San Antonio office (Daft, 2014, p.487). Creighton was instrumental in turning around a location that was underperforming. It was a location that had been on the verge of layoffs before he arrived (Daft, 2014, p.487). Now, the environment was more relaxed and the employees output had increased. The general consensus from his employees was that Creighton was a nice manager (Daft, 2014, p.488).
When the committee started discussing his potential for promotion, positive and negative traits were discovered. On the positive side, his location was now thriving and he had earned the trust of his employees. However, Mitch Ivey, a member of the committee, did not like the fact that Creighton had an “across-the-board reputation as a nice guy” (Daft, 2014, p.488). Ivey pointed out that many of the managers he had dealt with throughout his career were “respected, fair, and upfront”, but none had a reputation as being “nice” (Daft, 2014, p.487). Another committee member pointed out that Creighton had a reputation of “stepping in and he...

... middle of paper ...

... and productivity had increased at his facility (Daft, 2014, p.487). The turn around was so unexpected that he was able to make it to the finalist list for the promotion. He had a good “vision” for his facility and his employees trusted him (Daft, 2014, p.487). Knowing the positives will give him a foundation to build on.
Then, he needs to know the negative aspects of his job performance. He may not realize that being an overly nice manager is considered a negative trait for his career aspirations. In fact, he may not realize he is an overly nice manager in the first place. He needs to be advised to delegate more and participate less in the daily activities of his employees. Most of all, he needs to be encouraged to continue his growth as a manager.

Works Cited

Daft, R. L. (2013). Management, Limestone Custom Edition (11th ed.). Mason, OH: Cengage Learning

More about A Nice Manager

Open Document