A Comparison of The Signalman and The Darkness Out There

754 Words2 Pages

A Comparison of The Signalman and The Darkness Out There

'The Signalman' was set in an era in which Victorian language was

still used, meanwhile 'The Darkness Out There' is a more modern age

story. 'The Signalman', set 100 years before 'The Darkness Out There'

was the story of a troubled man. His troubles are the main reasons for

his death. The reader is unaware as to whether or not the Signalman's

death was a consequence of his paranoia or a matter of coincidence.'

The Darkness Out There' is an example of the cruelty within people,

though considered a horror story, the only horror in this story is

from the shock of Mrs.Rutter's lack of compassion for the German

pilot.'The Signalman' and 'The Darkness Out There' are similar and

different in many ways, I intend to compare two short stories, and in

my comparison I will find the similarities and differences in the

setting atmosphere and characterization.

'The Darkness Out There' was set in Britain a 100 years after 'The

Signalman' had the same rural setting. The narrator describes the edge

of the field, and the flowers, which make the reader, feel engrossed

in the "bright day" as she walks on the edge of the field. The setting

towards the beginning of the story is a warm summer day, the brighter

the day got the more the character, Sandra, seemed vulnerable to an

attack. As Sandra reaches 'Packer's End' the setting seems to change

from an innocent little girl walking through a beautiful field on a

warm day, to the dark and morbid place which was 'Packer's End'.

'Packer's End, described as "A rank place, all whippy saplings and

brambles and a gully with a dumped mattress and bedstead and...

... middle of paper ...

...n separate ways. Though 'The Signalman' was a horror story

it has a daunting atmosphere. The language though difficult to

understand, added to the horror of the story. "Whether there may have

been infection in his mind" certain words and phrases added to the

atmospheric tension. 'The Darkness Out There' in comparison to 'The

Signalman' wasn't as scary, but as effective in the message, both

stories were questioning reality, in 'The Signalman' the question was

to what extent was the spectre's appearance coincidence to the bad

happenings that occurred or was it's sudden appearance an omen? And in

'The Darkness Out There' the question was, was Mrs. Rutter's Actions

towards the German pilot, really as bad as Kerry and Sandra made it

out to be? And would it have been an out of the ordinary thing to do

during the time period?

Open Document