A Comparison Of Hamlet And Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet

1613 Words4 Pages

Different adaptations of William Shakespeare’s works have taken various forms. Through the creative license that artists, directors, and actors take, diverse incarnations of his classic works continue to arise. Gregory Doran’s Hamlet and Kenneth Branagh’s Hamlet bring William Shakespeare’s work by the same title to the screen. These two film adaptations take different approaches in presenting the turmoil of Hamlet. From the diverging takes on atmosphere to the characterization of the characters themselves, the many possible readings of Hamlet create the ability for the modification of the presentation and the meaning of the play itself. Doran presents David Tenant as Hamlet in a dark, eerie, and minimal setting; his direction highlighting the …show more content…

The setting of this scene is not only a metaphor for the internal character of Gertrude, but also functions as the platform on which Hamlet reveals how he feels about all of her transgressions. The use of the mirror as a metaphor is also warped from this point on, as the mirror is cracked and all reflections in the glass are distorted. The very same mirror that is shot in this scene is present when Ophelia gives her final monologue before she dies. She finds the freedom to speak her mind in her insanity and, arguably, the true, mentally fragmented reflection of her character is seen. The reflections and characterizations in the scene in Gertrude’s closet are consistent with Doran’s character driven rendition of Hamlet. Hamlet’s violence towards Gertrude continues, as he holds her head roughly and shows her the newspaper images of the late king and Claudius. This is an interesting part of the scene because Hamlet is describing the differences between the two men, when, in reality, both are played by the same actor, Patrick Stewart. In some ways, the queen marring her deceased husband’s “twin brother” results in an even more incestual feeling. This is troubling, yet keeps the focus upon the family drama of the play. While this scene unfolds, Gertrude is constantly afraid and on the verge of tears. This shows that she too is ashamed of …show more content…

Unsurprisingly, Branagh’s version of the scene in Gertrude’s closet contains many differences as well. Even in this scene so wrought with family peril, the focus of Branagh’s Hamlet remains on the theme of revenge. From the moment Hamlet arrives in Gertrude’s chamber there is a screaming match. Gertrude is indignant and insulted, rather than hurt and scared as in Doran’s portrayal. Even when Hamlet becomes more violent and physical with her, she still appears to be strong and a nearly even adversary. The killing of Polonius occurs in a similar fashion, except he is hidden behind a curtain rather than a mirror and Hamlet kills him with a dagger instead of a gun. This time period difference is vital in the playing out of this murder, because the “revenge” that takes place is much more personal with a dagger than with a gun. Hamlet is able to commit the murder from farther away with a gun, creating a less hands-on image of murder and revenge. During Hamlet’s line regarding revealing Gertrude’s innermost part, instead of simply referencing a mirror, the audience sees Hamlet try to forcefully undress her. Where in Doran’s film this disrobing was entirely figurative, Branagh takes it more literally in the scene’s staging. For most of the scene, Hamlet and Gertrude are leaning towards each other as if it is a heated argument, rather than Hamlet

More about A Comparison Of Hamlet And Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet

Open Document